• 56 Posts
  • 68 Comments
Joined 6 months ago
cake
Cake day: May 16th, 2024

help-circle




  • Nvidia definitely has a lot of skeletons in their closets with respect to anti-competitive practices.

    But even beyond that, any government would be within its right to start action against their dominance in the GPU compute space (e.g. making CUDA an open, independently managed, standard that Nvidia would have to do their absolute best to comply (or Huang would have proper liability, not american style).

    Same with their schemes around sanctions busting. If I was American, I would be extremely pissed off with how they are being handled with kids gloves for what is essentially treason (i.e. from my limited understanding the highest penalty in the US would be capital punishment).





  • Oh wow, I did not read the source Reuters article and yeah it’s a Chinese project.

    This is the kind of stuff that should make Americans evaluate whether their orthodox and somewhat parochial approach to “free speech” (the polemical definition as opposed to the broad concept) needs updating to reflect modern realities.

    Even before AI and digitization, there were many examples of how an American interpretation of free speech was clearly lacking, but this AI spam and strategic methods used by russia/China are going to make these deficiencies a much more pressing matter.


  • Fair point. I guess this was more of a casual post, so I didn’t think too much about it.

    I would have preferred if they switched to new keyboard model in version 8.x by default.

    I am a relatively light Linux user. Raspberry Pi headless via DietPi/Debian for NAS/Media server/torrents/PiHole and some experiments with self hosted services on major cloud services. I prefer to stick to defaults whenever possible.








  • I don’t mean to underestimate or playdown China’s potential. Being from the former (russia-occupied) USSR, I think both the west and global south severely underestimate and misunderstand the nature of China/Russia (and how to deal with them).

    What I am saying is that there are also inherent weaknesses to their economic and political systems that are often completely ignored; typically because they tend to be more medium/long term in nature.

    Hell, you can see it now with older chips at bigger physical nodes where China is now a significant portion of global production.

    Genuinely curious if you have any data on this.

    Will the PRC chip industry face many challenges? Of course it will. However, the PRC’s track record of going from nothing to 5nm in a few years cannot be ignored by TSMC.

    This is one example of “western” misinterpretation/misunderstanding of a regime such as China. While one should not casually dismiss their achievements, one should also be critical about their PR statement regarding 5nm.

    To my understanding their 5nm approach has yet to be delivered (show me a product with a 5nm chip) and its fundamentally unsuitable for mass scale production.

    It is reasonable to evaluate the role of “5nm” as a PR move and not as a working product.

    I would speculate even their “7nm” chips may be less competitively viable than one would think based on their use in Huawei’s smartphones. I could be wrong though, it’s difficult to find good information on this topic.






  • The development of PRC’s chip industry is not guaranteed to go on a exponential curve.

    There are inherently some disincentives to PRC’s approach to managing their chip industry, lots of money chasing limited productive projects (you can bet some opportunistic people in China are going to try and piggyback the money faucet). Essentially no-bid type contracts that are going to create a culture of stagnation (at least partially). Lack of a broad customer base (e.g. Apple essentially bankrolling new nodes at TSMC); global demand will always be way bigger and more sophisticated than China, Russia and Iran.

    Then you also have technical limitations like lack of access to hardware from ASML, more limited (and less competitive) tooling and design ecosystem.







  • I was young in the 90s/2000s and it honestly felt like computing was a new stage for human progress.

    I clearly wasn’t the only one. There was the “A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace” in 1996:

    Governments of the Industrial World, you weary giants of flesh and steel, I come from Cyberspace, the new home of Mind. On behalf of the future, I ask you of the past to leave us alone. You are not welcome among us. You have no sovereignty where we gather.

    I think the moral of all this is that fundamentally technology doesn’t matter. If you don’t have the public structures to reign in the oligarchs, shills and liars, you’re not going to get anywhere.