The “sometimes y” rule isn’t arbitrary, though. If the y makes a vowel sound then it’s a vowel in the context of that word. Vowels are the letters which represent sounds produced with an open vocal tract. It’s when y makes the “yuh” sound as in “yellow” that it isn’t a vowel because it requires constriction blocking the airway to produce the sound.
I was just learning about this today in response to this post! I had no idea that the definition of a vowel is based on what sound you actually make, rather than it having anything to do with what you write.
It’s kind of weird that it’s not taught that way in schools. Like, you’re just told a/e/I/o/u are the vowels and left to get on with it. Seems to me that could just be changed to “by the way it’s a/e/I/o/u/y/w, off you go”.
I can only imagine they’re downvoting because they’ve had a better education than me, or paid more attention in class, or read the Wikipedia entry ten minutes before me.
I majored in English at university and still had to double check Wikipedia to make sure I wasn’t talking out of my ass. There are so many grammatical rules that I only have a tiny understanding of.
Exactly! I mean, some people (looking at you downvoters) learnt that during their education. But I (we?) didn’t, and this has been a really interesting find for me.
I genuinely love learning about linguistic weirdness, I just don’t know a lot about it. Or have many occasions to learn.
I was once told on one croud-knowledge site that in English letters don’t imply sounds and there is no such thing as “this letter sounds like that in this word”
Makes me wonder what they would’ve told me about this “sometimes Y” rule that is exactly based on letter-sound correspondence
I’m not sure if I’m older or younger than you so IDK if it’s trending better or worse.
I’m late 30s, for reference. Also Canadian since that probably makes a difference.
I’m a little younger than you. I live in the US, but I was homeschooled in my early school years, so it’s possible the curriculum my mom used simply didn’t teach it. Or maybe I’ve simply forgotten they taught it.
Also by/dry/cry/pry etc. There are loads if you exclude y as a vowel.
The “sometimes y” rule isn’t arbitrary, though. If the y makes a vowel sound then it’s a vowel in the context of that word. Vowels are the letters which represent sounds produced with an open vocal tract. It’s when y makes the “yuh” sound as in “yellow” that it isn’t a vowel because it requires constriction blocking the airway to produce the sound.
So whether hospital has vowels depends on what country you are in and if you have insurance? /J
I’m Canadian, where the rule of hospitals is “i(nsurance for all) before e(xtreme corporate greed) except after c(onservatives are elected).”
I was just learning about this today in response to this post! I had no idea that the definition of a vowel is based on what sound you actually make, rather than it having anything to do with what you write.
It’s kind of weird that it’s not taught that way in schools. Like, you’re just told a/e/I/o/u are the vowels and left to get on with it. Seems to me that could just be changed to “by the way it’s a/e/I/o/u/y/w, off you go”.
Dunno why anyone would downvote you for this.
“Hey, this guy is trying to learn something that he wasn’t taught before! What an asshole!”
I can only imagine they’re downvoting because they’ve had a better education than me, or paid more attention in class, or read the Wikipedia entry ten minutes before me.
I majored in English at university and still had to double check Wikipedia to make sure I wasn’t talking out of my ass. There are so many grammatical rules that I only have a tiny understanding of.
Exactly! I mean, some people (looking at you downvoters) learnt that during their education. But I (we?) didn’t, and this has been a really interesting find for me.
I genuinely love learning about linguistic weirdness, I just don’t know a lot about it. Or have many occasions to learn.
I was once told on one croud-knowledge site that in English letters don’t imply sounds and there is no such thing as “this letter sounds like that in this word”
Makes me wonder what they would’ve told me about this “sometimes Y” rule that is exactly based on letter-sound correspondence
IDK what they’re teaching these days, but back in my day (😭) it was
Back in my day, we didn’t even have “and sometimes Y”.
I’m not sure if I’m older or younger than you so IDK if it’s trending better or worse. I’m late 30s, for reference. Also Canadian since that probably makes a difference.
I’m a little younger than you. I live in the US, but I was homeschooled in my early school years, so it’s possible the curriculum my mom used simply didn’t teach it. Or maybe I’ve simply forgotten they taught it.