Why do people assume Signal messenger isn’t spying on you? Yes, it has open source code, yes it uses end-to-end encryption. But we can’t check which code runs in the version from Google Play or the App Store. And also their APK (IPA) build process is essentially a black box, it doesn’t use GitHub Actions or some other transparent build system. I also heard from Techlore that they add a proprietary part to the apk to filter bots. The only thing I can assume is that people scanned the traffic coming from the app (Android), phone (iOS) and checked whether encryption keys were being sent to Signal or not. But it seems to me that this can be also circumvented. What do you think?

P.S. I myself use Signal to communicate with relatives and friends. Definetly not a hater.

  • august_senpai@lemm.ee
    48·
    1 year ago

    Because they were brought to court to give info for a case and they proved they didn’t have any.

    • poVoq@slrpnk.net
      53·
      1 year ago

      This is only for retro-active cases. A judge can perfectly well order them to do live surveillance of users and put it all under a gag-order and have the police ex-filtrate the data so that Signal can still claim they are not storing any of it.

      Like all centralized services their claims to privacy are very shallow and the FBI is known to have tried to get paid informants on these large messenger companies to ex-filtrate data even without the above mentioned legal way via a court order.

        • poVoq@slrpnk.net
          21·
          1 year ago

          First of all yes they can, and secondly that’s not a new feature but any server has that built in by default. The question is just, is it stored or not.

    • FarLine99@lemm.eeOP
      414·
      1 year ago

      From whom did this information come, from Signal themselves? It’s like asking a criminal if you stole diamonds in that store at 3 a.m. And again, they may have disclosed these messages to the government, but together they agreed to say that Signal does not have anything. I think we need to think about such things 😉

      • Netto Hikari@social.fossware.spaceEnglish
        15·
        1 year ago

        They’d be jeopardizing everything if they lied in such a situation.

        There are still a few companies out there who truly stand for one’s freedom and privacy. Look at what happened to Mullvad VPN, for example. They were raided and there was nothing to be found, because their no-logs policy was actually true.