• oatscoop@midwest.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    14
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    11 months ago

    So … what part of that has anything to do with a farmer getting screwed when their equipment breaks down and they’re locked out of effecting a repair they’re more than capable of doing?

    When they’re racing time and the weather waiting on an overbooked repair tech that can get them in at their convenience a few days from now, and charge an arm and a leg for the pleasure? Who’s liable to tell them they need to bring it to the shop 50+ miles away?

    Sure: they could buy another brand … that doesn’t work as nearly as well. That’s not compatible with the $500k+ of JD equipment and attachments they already own. That isn’t well supported in their region.

    Farmers aren’t pissed because JD is preventing them from doing stupid shit. They’re pissed because JD is using every anti-consumer practice in the book to extract as much money as possible from a captive market and fucking them at the same time.

    warranty

    Warranties don’t cover damage from abuse, misuse, and user modifications already.

    • ikidd@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      6
      ·
      11 months ago

      YOU CAN BUY ALL THE PARTS YOU NEED TO FIX YOUR TRACTOR.

      The person you’re replying to is absolutely correct. The only thing you can’t do is legally modify the firmware on the controllers because that is usually done to bypass emissions controls. There are 10,000 page manuals supplied by Deere to diagnose and repair every part of their machinery. I have used them many times. I have never taken a tractor in to a Deere dealer to repair for any other reason than “I don’t have time to deal with this right now”.

      Jesus, the misinformation on this subject is depressing, as is the willingness of people to accept it without a hint of critical thinking or research.

      • oatscoop@midwest.social
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        11 months ago

        The only thing you can’t do is legally modify the firmware on the controllers because that is usually done to bypass emissions controls

        We are talking about basic access to the software in a way that allows diagnosing and repairing problems.

        Every major part of a tractor is computer controlled and “smart”, and because of that JD locks the owner out from accessing diagnostic information or swapping parts. Doing so requires hooking up a laptop with JD Service Advisor – which isn’t available to anyone apart from JD service techs.

        The GPS module (or any other “smart” part) died and you want to swap it with an identical spare you have on hand? Tough shit, you need to call a tech to hook their laptop up before the computer will accept the new part. Want “trouble codes” to diagnose a problem – too bad, you don’t have JD Service Advisor to pull them. Fix a problem and want to take the tractor out of “trouble mode” … nope.

        As for “modifying firmware”: the firmware controls everything. You can’t use 3rd party parts, and you can’t even use older (but still working) John Deere parts that are “unsupported”.

        Jesus, the misinformation on this subject is depressing

        Yeah, by people that have obviously never touched JD equipment.

        • ikidd@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          11 months ago

          There are hundreds of diagnostic addresses and values you can pull up on the minidisplays on every piece of equipment, as well as diagnostic codes that have been more than sufficient to use to follow the diagnostic procedures the Deere provides in any case that I’ve ever dealt with. That diagnostic manual is another 10,000 page manual that deere supplies and if you’re bright enough, you can fix anything. The wire numbers, circuit diagrams, test procedures, etc, etc, etc are all in there, but most farmers can’t be arsed to buy a multimeter it would seem. Most farmers that bitch about R2R wouldn’t grease their own combine if they can help it, let alone replace a turbo.

          There are a certain number of parts like stepper motors etc that have CanBUS addresses that need to be programmed into the controllers so they can address the part correctly over J1939. So in those rare cases, I’ve gotten a tech to drive by on their way to another call, and spent $50 having them sync up the address, it’s not difficult. We are able to buy the JDSA systems now but it’s very much not worth the cost, $26000 the last time I checked.

          And you’re plain wrong about the GPS, I’ve swapped around antennas and moved around 2630 systems with no need to call anyone. I think they’re overpriced shit compared to what I can build myself with AgOpenGPS, but they work fine for the standard idiot.

          obviously never touched JD equipment

          Pretty sure I know which one of us that describes.